There is nothing quite like stumbling across a designer label at a thrift store. I remember being 21 and scoring my first-ever thrift store find: a sage double-breasted Burberry blazer, complete with a sewn-on emblem on the chest and intricate gold buttons. It still bore the old Burberrys label before the label dropped the “S” in 1999. Beyond fuelling my hedonistic desire to emulate the Balmain pseudo-military look of the 2010s, I also felt the immense rush of wondering if I had “cheated the system”. Am I potentially owning a piece of Burberry history — could it be runway, perhaps? — for exactly RM50 because some underpaid staff could ascertain that it was something of value? As I Googled “mint green Burberry double-breasted jacket” in the changing room, nothing came up except for a few listings on Mercari and Yahoo! Japan. Still green to fashion, but knowledgeable enough to throw in some jargon, I proudly declared the piece as vintage to friends and family who asked. Was it really, though? The piece is now sitting in storage, but the novelty remains.
Every fashion enthusiast reaches a point in their journey and discovers secondhand clothing. When your taste and wants outpace your disposable income, shopping pre-loved becomes the most viable option for self-expression, rather than trudging to the nearest Zara and still dropping a fortune for a look. As you are done rummaging through racks at Second Street or listings on Carousell, you will eventually find yourself graduating on to platforms like Grailed or TheRealReal, hoping to secure something more elusive. Headline after headline fast-tracks the phenomenon, driven by celebrity stylists like Law Roach and personalities like Zendaya and Kim Kardashian, who no longer consider the current season’s offerings a flex. It is either fresh off the runway or relics of the past, usually reserved for the museum or immortalised on Getty Images.
On a larger scale, you start noticing the spillover effect: not only is there interest in acquiring these pieces themselves, but prices also surge on any and every piece with a designer label. You see the worn-out Courrèges polo tee and the peeling Westwood bowling bag in a corner with a triple-digit price tag and wonder: “Really?” Do all secondhand clothing eventually qualify as vintage? How many of these earn their label of being an archival piece? Are they valuable by virtue of sentimental value or preserving something no longer replicable?
Among resellers, collectors and enthusiasts, little distinguishes what qualifies a piece as vintage from what is merely secondhand. “Vintage clothing generally refers to clothing distinguishable by the era it originates from. Most people consider a garment vintage if it’s at least 20 years old,” shares Ilyas, a 22-year-old reseller and collector who is part of the team behind FIFTH. However, according to Vegas Lee, co-founder and curator of Upstairs Garments in Singapore, social media has left labels like secondhand, vintage and archival clothing befuddled. “The meaning behind these labels may vary depending on who you ask. Secondhand clothing is the catch-all term for pieces that were once owned by someone else, so archival pieces also fall under that category. ‘True Vintage’, a sub-label of vintage, refers to pieces before the 1980s that originate from the original factory, from a time when documentation is scarce. These kinds of pieces retain specific materials, hardware, and craftsmanship that might no longer exist.” To Malaysian collector and reseller Faiz Darwiis, vintage clothing means non-designer pieces that had some form of impact in the fashion industry. “ I consider band tees, rap tees, and American collegiate-style tees as vintage because you can distinguish the era they originated from. Clothing from the 1970s had this skinny, flared and colourful vibe that reflected the subcultures of the time, while rock and grunge movements influenced the aesthetics of the 1980s and 1990s,” he adds. Alternatively, archival fashion refers to designer pieces that have an industry-wide impact or mark a turning point in a designer’s career.
“Let it be the material, design or the designer himself. Not every designer piece can be considered an archive. Raf Simons’ infamous bomber jacket from Fall Winter 2001 ‘Riot Riot Riot!’ was once an unpopular piece, going for as low as £50. Fast forward to the 2010s, you spot folks like Kanye West and Drake wearing it — cementing it as a piece of archive.”
Every designer has their own charm that catapults them to archival status. “My personal favourite is Tom Ford’s tenure at Gucci and Yves Saint Laurent. Sleek, sexy and erotic, Tom Ford changed the course of fashion history forever with the transformation of the house of Gucci by modernising it. Ann Demeulemeester’s legendary run at her eponymous label is one of my favourites, too. As a member of the Antwerp Six, her design ethos focuses on dark romanticism, a monochromatic palette, and androgyny,” shares Ilyas. Collector Barry Ooi is drawn to Carol Christian Poell’s (CCP) manipulation and treatment of leather. “As he comes from a family of leather crafting and tanning, his craftsmanship combined with formal tailoring is unmatched, especially during his peak between 2008 and 2010.” Separately, Ong Ker Hsien of Upstairs Garments feels he can relentlessly champion his raw, authentic self when he wears Hedi Slimane’s designs. “His clothes are made for my body type, empowering the slim and those who are overlooked or condescended to for their meekness. Through his aggressive cut and rebellious music that was set against societal norms, I found familiarity in his work, which gave me a sense of community.”
Most people misunderstand vintage and archive fashion, thinking any old piece is vintage and that an old designer piece qualifies as archival. “When you look up the piece, it’s not even on the runway or documented in any form of media,” notes Faiz. According to Ilyas, the “archival” label has become a marketing buzzword used to sell vintage clothing. “Owning a piece and understanding its place within the fashion world are two very different things. The word ‘archive’ should communicate your knowledge of the piece, not just its price and exclusivity.” Ooi adds that the phenomenon of intimidation and gatekeeping among brands like CCP that have been treated as esoteric cults has led people to think one requires deep institutional knowledge before they are allowed to enjoy the brand.
“You don’t need permission or a fashion degree to enjoy a garment. If you connect with it, that’s enough.” Another misconception is that people think they are inherently expensive. Adrienne Chrisdee, a fellow co-founder of Upstairs Garments, believes that pricing in the resale market is completely distorted.
“Consumers today routinely overpay for secondhand garments that have played zero role in a brand’s history or creative journey — potentially due to what they consume online.” On a more nefarious note, she also believes that the hype around reselling has ultimately gentrified thrifting. “In markets like Singapore, we see ordinary, late-model secondhand clothes marked up as ‘vintage’, turning what was once a financial necessity into a trendy commodity. This inflates prices across the board, ultimately squeezing out the low-income communities who rely on affordable secondhand stores.”
While limited supply of archival clothing will play a role in pricing, hype and notoriety have aggressively driven up prices in the archive fashion market, with examples like Hedi Slimane’s designs for Dior Homme. “I believe many archival pieces will hold their value, but some may not stand the test of time due to how they are a part of a trend cycle,” observes Ilyas. However, price alone is not a strong enough indicator of actual demand. “Yes, prices continue to increase, but the demand is no longer as good as it once was. People can price things however they want, but it might not result in a sale. Five years ago, you could list Raf Simons or Helmut Lang pieces at whatever price and people would still buy them. The price has since remained, but the pieces remain unsold on Grailed, because people have already moved on,” Faiz explains. Lee remains hopeful that prices will eventually go down. “The new wave of ‘archive’ is driven by hype and plays heavily into the fear of missing out. Labels without anything special, or mall brands, are now branded as archival. So buy what you like and not base your purchase off someone on a screen. Brands like Comme des Garçons have been relatively stagnant in prices except extremely rare pieces.” Ooi also believes the hype bubble has popped. “During the peak of streetwear mania, you would witness insane anomalies like a viral jacket selling for $40,000 or people flipping mass-produced Supreme logos. Once that trend faded, streetwear folks migrated toward archival fashion, but even then, those prices started to stabilise and dip. The market is correcting itself as consumers realise the rarity engineered purely by social media hype isn’t sustainable.” When asked about trends that will not stand the test of time, the opium style alongside the flat, ballet-style shoes come to mind. “People used to want the bulky, Balenciaga-style shoes, but now everyone is leaning towards flats. In the future, people will no longer value what they consider valuable now,” shares Faiz. Ilyas foresees Japanese mall brands like G.O.A., Tornado Mart, and Semantic Designs, once made popular by the Visual Kei fad that took the Internet by storm in 2024, becoming less relevant.
Could the appeal of vintage and archival clothing be attributed to the quality of the pieces? Are clothes from the past just better made? Or is the appeal more about scarcity and owning something most can no longer access? Lee believes the first statement to be undeniably true. “I have pieces from the 1970s to the present day, and nothing can match the quality and tailoring of the past. And no, I don’t think scarcity plays a role when I build my wardrobe. Pieces from the past are a true testament to quality. However, contemporary designers like John Alexander Skelton, who uses British tailors’ techniques and deadstock fabric, still honour the old ways of making clothes.” Ong believes the overall benchmark for quality has lowered because of increased demand and conglomerates seeking higher margins, which lead to poorer fabrics and weaker quality control. “High quality clothing still exists with better quality fabrics; just take traditional menswear for example. Many fabric makers have extensively improved on their merino wool, cashmere, and other materials.” Ilyas and Faiz believe that both scarcity and quality impact the allure of archival pieces. “Humans were more involved in the process of making clothes, and fewer were made,” says Faiz. While Ilyas believes a garment’s longevity is testament to its quality and craftsmanship, he also recognises that, for some people, having something nobody else has is a form of social currency.
As vintage clothing has somewhat become shorthand for those new to fashion to signal credibility, we now witness resellers and buyers attempting to pass off anything with a designer label as valuable. Is this considered fair play in the game of supply and demand? “Just because something carries a Margiela tag doesn’t automatically mean it’s valuable or worth thousands of dollars. The problem arises when buyers blindly purchase without considering whether the garment aligns with their personal style or body type. Educated sellers like Archive Gems in KL and Upstairs Garments in Singapore, however, carefully contextualise the historical importance of a piece,” shares Ooi. While Lee acknowledges that sellers will overfluff something to maximise gain before moving on to the next big thing, timelessness will ultimately persevere. “Christophe Decarnin’s Balmain is now making mad waves online after everyone milked Hedi’s Celine and Dior Homme. This is why we turn away from certain labels and only curate what we genuinely buy and wear,” he says. Adding on, Chrisdee does not see this as a mere game of supply and demand, as it ignores how heavily the market relies on hype and information gaps. “Resellers manufacture demand by rebranding ordinary, mass-produced pieces as rare, archival, or vintage. Because newcomers use designer tags as a shortcut to fashion credibility, they pay exorbitant markups simply for a physical receipt that brands them as cool.” When the sole focus is on the brand tag and nothing else, consumers become wilfully blind to what makes a piece truly special.
Given that brands such as Dior and Gucci have licensed their brands to third-party suppliers in the past, these offerings further blur what it means to own an “authentic” piece of the brand. The team at Upstairs Garments believes licensing generally does not come with good quality, even if it opens up a whole new market for certain brands. “Labels like Vivienne Westwood & Burberry have created Japan-exclusive labels that differ heavily in quality. Westwood’s Red Label targeted the youth, while Burberry’s Black Label, which was made under Sanyo Shokai, produced really great stuff. Margiela’s entry to Japan via Kokonoe Corp has produced some really good mainline-quality stuff. So it depends.” Ilyas adds on by saying that the pieces that are typically made under a Japanese license are well-made by today’s standards. The issue comes down to ascribing the value of a piece based on label alone. “Especially in Malaysia, when they notice that the tag is Dior, Gucci or something, they automatically label the piece as archive. But this is where knowledge matters, and you need to know what you’re buying into. Sometimes it’s not the same quality,” Faiz explains.
For those who are looking to begin their journey as collectors, Ilyas recommends building the acumen to know where and how to spot steals. “There are so many online resources and guides to help you authenticate and date vintage items. That is how I found out many of my stuff is archival. It only takes a few minutes to check.”
According to Faiz, collecting vintage means having realistic expectations. “For vintage items, you might notice some distressing that adds to the character. You can compare prices to the market, and plenty of platforms let shoppers do so. It really depends on how eager you are to own the item. Some people are willing to pay above the market rate as long as they’re able to procure something authentic.” Ultimately, it is about finding something that truly works for you. “Only buy if it fits you, no matter how nice an item is. An item only has value if I were to sell it, so if I’m going to wear it myself, the item is priceless,” shares the team at Upstairs Garments.
Once you are done with this story, click here to catch up with our November 2026 issue.